Skip to content

Does Naplan Testing Do More Harm Than Good?

New research raises questions about the effects of the National Assessment Program-- Literacy And Numeracy (NAPLAN) on the health and wellbeing of trainees and on favorable teaching and finding out techniques. NAPLAN was presented to enhance literacy and numeracy in Australian primary and secondary schools, however the question needs to be asked: is it worth it?

The suite of tests that comprise NAPLAN, administered in Years 3, 5, 7 and 9, are intended to determine three things: first, how individual students are performing; 2nd, the degree to which nationwide literacy and numeracy standards are being achieved at each school; and third, how well curricula are working in Australian schools.

Seven years of NAPLAN testing have actually produced combined outcomes.

Our group hung out in five school neighborhoods (in Victoria and New South Wales) where we interviewed trainees, parents, instructors and school principals. The report is potentially the most considerable to date as it is the first to study the influence on students.

What did the research find?

The findings reveal that, versus its mentioned objectives, NAPLAN is at best a blunt tool.

The outcomes aren't universally negative. Some teachers find the results informative, there is proof that in some schools NAPLAN results have actually been a trigger to implement literacy and numeracy programs, and some parents appreciate the simple assessment of their kids's achievement levels.

The research reveals that NAPLAN is afflicted by negative effects on student wellness and learning. Our previous study of teachers discovered that 90% of teachers reported that trainees felt stressed out prior to taking the test.

This study of trainee experiences of NAPLAN draws attention to the need to take student wellness into account in instructional efforts. While Australian instructional policies do not clearly state all procedures should remain in the very best interests of the children, they ought to comply with the ethical practice of "doing no damage".

The numerous unexpected effects of NAPLAN originate from the failure to take the interests of all trainees seriously. The formal and inflexible design of NAPLAN is not conducive to learning and teaching methods that stress deep learning.

NAPLAN, which uses language and a design of testing that is frequently foreign to trainees, strays from the systems integrated in class that promote learning.

Our report found that a majority of trainees disliked NAPLAN and were unsure of its function. A majority reported sensations of tension.

Those who were struggling in mathematics and/or literacy were the most nervous about whether they would stop working. Worryingly, schools reported that these trainees (whom the tests are created to assist) were typically the ones least most likely to sit the tests. A smaller sized proportion reported specific stress-related conditions such as insomnia, hyperventilation, excessive sweating, nail biting, headaches, stomach pains and migraines.

Majority desire NAPLAN ditched

When asked exactly what message they wish to give to the Australian federal government about NAPLAN, a bulk of respondents suggested that it needs to be scrapped.

However, numerous also made suggestions about how NAPLAN could be made more relevant (through using better examples and more available language) and how to lower levels of tension. Those in favour of NAPLAN focused on the chance it supplies students to practise the art of sitting tests.

The comprehensive analysis of trainees' experiences in 5 varied Australian communities contained in our report supplies the first methodical analysis of the impact of NAPLAN testing on trainees. It reinforces the views of lots of parents, school principals and teachers: that NAPLAN has substantial unintended consequences, which have a negative impact on the quality of learning and student wellness.

Although NAPLAN testing is designed to improve the quality of education youths get in Australia, its application, misuses and utilizes mean that it weakens quality education and does harm that is not in the very best interests of Australian kids.

What It's Like To Research Study English At York

I'm now halfway through my time in York as an English trainee, and I have actually been enjoying every minute of it. Here's some things I want I 'd understood about the course before starting uni:

You learn that there is a whole wide world of literatures (Yes, with the plural's'!).

One fantastic aspect of the York English Lit structure is that it exposes students to English Literature across time periods and across continents, and enables you to find authors you have actually never heard of in the past. In your first year, you'll start with a module that consists of texts from the 15th century all the way to the contemporary. In readings, lectures and workshops, discussion of these texts likewise always involves conversations of the major historic events of that duration, how life was like because era, and obviously, important philosophical and cultural readings of the text (something which I have actually grown to truly delight in reading).

In another module, York's English program exposes us to international literatures, centred around styles such as post-colonialism (the Literature of nations who were ex-British nests, for instance). Personally, I found that to be an extremely enhancing experience that broadened my worldview and triggered me to consider the relationship between Literature and Politics, and to question the function of a literary text.

This may sound a little complicated, but it actually isn't really so! You absolutely can expect to discover studying English at uni to be greatly various from the way we did it at A Levels, and while I did feel rather stressed in the very first few weeks of term, I ultimately found my footing and grew to love the volume and speed of work we have at uni. Also, it offers you a huge sense of achievement when you recall at the end of the term at all the poems, plays and novels you've gone through in just 10 weeks!

The large direct exposure to several periods of literature makes you discover interests in topics you never ever engaged with in the past. For me, post-colonialism was my newfound love.

Versatility, flexibility, flexibility!

Studying English at York is awesome because the course provides you a lot of self-reliance to direct your research studies. The English course has fairly few contact hours (a.k.a. time invested in lectures and seminars) as compared to other subjects. The coolest thing about the English course would be that you get to decide exactly what you want to write you essay on-- there are no set questions (conserve for the written tests in summer season term)!

Having more versatility with your timetable also indicates that you can use the time to sign up with more societies and even take up a term-time internship, which was exactly what I did! Through the York Careers Portal, I applied for a term-time internship lasting for 12 weeks in Communications, and spent roughly 12 hours a week at the internship, which corresponds to about 3 days a week. This assisted me gain work experience and employability abilities, as well as some extra income on the side.

We have film screenings.

We enjoy film adaptations of some of the texts in our reading lists (side note: I love how these sessions show up on our schedule as legit compulsory lectures to go to)! Who 'd have thought that studying English at uni also includes being in a dark lecture theatre and viewing a film predicted on to the substantial screen? Consider it as a Netflix movie date ... but with a whole lot of individuals.

In my first year, I keep in mind seeing A Midsummer's Night Dream and caring how the motion picture represented the characters of the play a lot that I composed among my essays on the play! And just last term, seeing Samuel Beckett's Endgame throughout a film screening made me see the play in a whole various light, prompting me to obtain 3 various books from the library about Beckett and his works.

They're not going to let you be puzzled and stressed all by yourself.

We're assigned an individual supervisor at the start of university, and this manager will be an academic from your department-- in our case, English-- and you 'd satisfy him/her regularly throughout your three years of study to simply chat about how you're discovering the course and how you're feeling, if you're coping well or if you're having an issue about module choices, and so on.

What It's Like To Research Study English At York

I'm now halfway through my time in York as an English trainee, and I have actually been enjoying every minute of it. Here's some things I want I 'd understood about the course before starting uni:

You learn that there is a whole wide world of literatures (Yes, with the plural's'!).

One fantastic aspect of the York English Lit structure is that it exposes students to English Literature across time periods and across continents, and enables you to find authors you have actually never heard of in the past. In your first year, you'll start with a module that consists of texts from the 15th century all the way to the contemporary. In readings, lectures and workshops, discussion of these texts likewise always involves conversations of the major historic events of that duration, how life was like because era, and obviously, important philosophical and cultural readings of the text (something which I have actually grown to truly delight in reading).

In another module, York's English program exposes us to international literatures, centred around styles such as post-colonialism (the Literature of nations who were ex-British nests, for instance). Personally, I found that to be an extremely enhancing experience that broadened my worldview and triggered me to consider the relationship between Literature and Politics, and to question the function of a literary text.

This may sound a little complicated, but it actually isn't really so! You absolutely can expect to discover studying English at uni to be greatly various from the way we did it at A Levels, and while I did feel rather stressed in the very first few weeks of term, I ultimately found my footing and grew to love the volume and speed of work we have at uni. Also, it offers you a huge sense of achievement when you recall at the end of the term at all the poems, plays and novels you've gone through in just 10 weeks!

The large direct exposure to several periods of literature makes you discover interests in topics you never ever engaged with in the past. For me, post-colonialism was my newfound love.

Versatility, flexibility, flexibility!

Studying English at York is awesome because the course provides you a lot of self-reliance to direct your research studies. The English course has fairly few contact hours (a.k.a. time invested in lectures and seminars) as compared to other subjects. The coolest thing about the English course would be that you get to decide exactly what you want to write you essay on-- there are no set questions (conserve for the written tests in summer season term)!

Having more versatility with your timetable also indicates that you can use the time to sign up with more societies and even take up a term-time internship, which was exactly what I did! Through the York Careers Portal, I applied for a term-time internship lasting for 12 weeks in Communications, and spent roughly 12 hours a week at the internship, which corresponds to about 3 days a week. This assisted me gain work experience and employability abilities, as well as some extra income on the side.

We have film screenings.

We enjoy film adaptations of some of the texts in our reading lists (side note: I love how these sessions show up on our schedule as legit compulsory lectures to go to)! Who 'd have thought that studying English at uni also includes being in a dark lecture theatre and viewing a film predicted on to the substantial screen? Consider it as a Netflix movie date ... but with a whole lot of individuals.

In my first year, I keep in mind seeing A Midsummer's Night Dream and caring how the motion picture represented the characters of the play a lot that I composed among my essays on the play! And just last term, seeing Samuel Beckett's Endgame throughout a film screening made me see the play in a whole various light, prompting me to obtain 3 various books from the library about Beckett and his works.

They're not going to let you be puzzled and stressed all by yourself.

We're assigned an individual supervisor at the start of university, and this manager will be an academic from your department-- in our case, English-- and you 'd satisfy him/her regularly throughout your three years of study to simply chat about how you're discovering the course and how you're feeling, if you're coping well or if you're having an issue about module choices, and so on.